Not only are the Mariners terrible, but on Friday, they were fighting each other in the dugout. That’s no atmosphere for a 34-year old slugger who kills right-handed pitching. Get Russell Branyan out of there.
While the Mariners traded for Branyan on June 26th (from Cleveland), it doesn’t make much sense for them to keep him. They’re a terrible baseball team, he’s 34, and they have three first basemen on their roster (Smoak, Kotchman). Why Seattle traded for him in the first place is a bit of a mystery, considering their current state of affairs.
However, he would make a solid addition to the Yankees as the other half of a Marcus Thames DH platoon, and an upgrade over Juan Miranda. Let’s operate under the assumption (or pretend) that Cashman is still willing to deal with Jack-Z after the Cliff Lee ordeal.
Here’s why Branyan fits:
1. 2010 contract is for $1.5 million, which means he likely only has about $700k left on it (to the Yankees, that’s the equivalent of one of us finding $5.00 in our pants before we do laundry). He does have a $5 mil option for 2011, with a $500k buyout.
2. Over the last 3 seasons, he’s averaged a slugging-heavy OPS+ of 130.
3. His power is straight silly. His 2010 IsoP of .237 is higher than any Yankee, and he’s done it this season in two pitcher-friendly parks.
4. He punishes right-handed pitching. Last 3 years vs. RHP: 252/.351/.542 (.422 wOBA in 2008!). This year: .242/.340/.500 (.378 wOBA).
A Thames/Branyan platoon would be a feast or famine type set-up, but if used correctly, lots of balls could be flying around (maturity here, people). You’re looking at some serious power from the DH spot.



26 Comments
Steve Phillips July 24, 2010 11:25
I would trade Montero, Joba, and Brackman to get this bat into Yankee Stadium. I also like fat ugly interns.
Ken Rosenthal July 24, 2010 14:07
Sources say that Seattle is open to trading Branyan for a used lawnmower and Steve Balboni
Steve Phillips July 24, 2010 16:12
I would take that deal if I were the GM of the New York Yankees. Then again, I’ll never have another front office job.
Phieleblunt July 24, 2010 16:32
You forgot Reason #5:
He is not Nick Johnson
Steve Phillips July 24, 2010 17:48
I would trade Stephan Strasburg to Houston for Roy Ostwalt to go for it this year. NO REALLY I SAID THIS. Yes people pay me money to hear talk about baseball because I’m an expert.
Eric Karros July 24, 2010 19:22
My hair is higher than Cheech.
Shane Spencer July 24, 2010 20:18
I’m your answer.
Rob Deer July 24, 2010 21:27
No, I’m the answer. Plus I have a mustache.
CC July 24, 2010 23:05
Just let me DH on my off days.
Always bet on black.
cockgobbler July 24, 2010 23:37
Why all the animosity with N. Johnson. It’s not like he wants to get hurt.
Alvaro Espinoza July 25, 2010 06:08
trade joba for a coffee with 2 add shots
Bubba Crosby July 25, 2010 14:51
I’m retired.
Sky Is Falling July 25, 2010 19:34
“Why all the animosity with N. Johnson. It’s not like he wants to get hurt.”
Seriously? I hope this is a joke. Just in case it isn’t… Carl Pavano. Also, Johnson sucks. There were about 15 better options available at the time. I’d rather have Matsui out there. Just for the hell of it, I’d even rather have an injured Matsui on the DL than an injured Johnson, if only for the World Series and career highlights.
cockgobbler July 25, 2010 19:57
About 15 better options? Come on…
Clay Bellinger July 25, 2010 20:07
Ignore these idiots, i’m the man for DH
Carl Pavano July 25, 2010 20:16
I’m 12 and 6 with 5 complete games hows my dictate.
Chris Brown July 25, 2010 21:55
Sign me up. I know how to HIT, yo!
Sensitive RAB guy July 26, 2010 02:18
@Cockgobbler — yeah, Nick Johnson doesn’t want to get hurt … but on the other hand, fatboy isn’t gonna return any of the millions he’s making for eating Fritos all yr.
And I’d invite you over to our site, but you’d have to change your screen-name…
Steve July 26, 2010 09:18
Branyan would be a good fit, but I can’t see Cashman dealing with the Mariners for a while. The Yankees were pissed about the Lee dealings. Unless that’s all media created bullcrap, which it could be.
Steve July 26, 2010 09:45
Let’s all constantly complain about the guy on the DL who is only making $5M while the team is still on pace for 104 wins!!
Nick Johnson got hurt. Let it go. They’ll find another bat.
Brian July 26, 2010 09:57
If the team is on pace for 104 wins then why do they need another bat? Branyan isn’t very good and not a guy the Yanks need to trade for before the deadline since they could just as easily claim him off waivers if they become desperate for a guy who either K’s or hits a HR.
Dave Cameron July 26, 2010 10:04
Buy a ticket to hear me talk about how smart I am.
Steve July 26, 2010 10:10
I’m not saying they need Branyan, or that they even have to get a bat, but I am sure they will do something to tinker with their roster. And that might impact the DH spot in some way. Either they will grab a competent player that can play 3B/SS, which improves the DH with A-Rod and Jeter getting time there. Or another OFer/DH.
My point was really that Johnson was a mistake, but in the grand scheme of things, it was a small mistake that can easily be fixed/absorbed.
J July 27, 2010 09:29
Branyan’s OPS against righties this year is .840? Thames’s is .835. Just sayin’ is all…
Shelley Duncan July 28, 2010 09:25
Hey guys! Remember me?
Layne Zimm January 21, 2011 12:28
Thank you, baby carrots, the ideal mindless stress eating snack. Because of you I can really focus on mindless Internet surfing.