It is sad to read the boilerplate groupthink that the power-worshipping so-called sports “journalists” of the mainstream media put out these days. Yankee ownership is charting a course that is different than anything we’ve seen in team history — purposefully conceding wins in the standings in order to pocket millions of dollars that their fans have invested in the team.
But the media has either completely failed to take notice, or is turning a blind-eye to ownership’s abnegation of their responsibility to their fans. Everyone from ESPN to the local beat writers are treating this as just another typical offseason. Joel Sherman is still writing whole columns discussing the possibility of the Yankees signing Josh Hamilton!
Despite the mass delusion, NoMaas remembers a time when Yankee fans could have very different expectations for what might come off the hot stove. We had our staff historians dig through the dusty archives and they found some very interesting tidbits from pinstriped times of yore. For example, let’s take a look at one of these ancient offseasons — circa 2009 anno Domini:
- The Yankees are coming off a year where they invested over $400 million to retain Alex Rodriguez, Jorge Posada, Mariano Rivera, and Andy Pettitte. But after missing the playoffs for the first time since 1994, they decide they need to do whatever it takes to make sure that doesn’t happen again.
- Brian Cashman starts things off by acquiring Nick Swisher on November 13th, 2008 for Wilson Betemit and two minor league pitchers whose names you don’t remember.
- On December 12th, the Yankees sign the second-best pitcher available on the free agent market — AJ Burnett — for 5 years/$82.5 million (which wasn’t a good idea and we said so at the time, but the front office thought they were upgrading).
- The very next day, the Yankees officially sign the very best pitcher available on the free agent market — CC Sabathia –for 7 years/$161 million.
- Three weeks later they swoop in and outbid the Red Sox for the very best position player available — Mark Teixeira — for 8 years/$180 million.
Apparently there is something to this method, as the Yankees rewarded their fans with their 27th World Series. Amidst the euphoric afterglow, the Yankees still found room to add Curtis Granderson and Javier Vazquez (who didn’t work out, but was coming off of a 2.87 ERA 2009 season).
Now fast forward, and compare all this to the Yankees current offseason to date:
- The front office signs no new players, but is able to retain three players — with an average age of 40 years old — because they only want to play with the Yankees and are willing to take discounts from their market value.
- They make it clear they have no interest in retaining perennial 4-win player Nick Swisher, even if he’s going to sign for a reasonable price.
-The Yankees watch the Red Sox sign David Ross at a bargain price, and then don’t even make Russell Martin an offer as he goes to Pittsburgh for a very reasonable 2 years/$17 million. Then Mike Napoli also signs with Boston.
- After ARod is forced to have hip surgery, the Yankees are left with no rightfielder, no catcher, and no third baseman. But they pass on matching 1 year / $3 million for Eric Chavez.
- Josh Hamilton and Zach Greinke — a top 5 hitter and top 5 pitcher, respectively — are available as free agents. The Yankees don’t consider even making an offer to either.
Comparing these offseasons is like looking at those before and after pictures of meth addicts.
There is one possible silver lining to this for Yankee fans. While the current modus operandi makes no baseball sense, it does make business sense for an ownership that is looking to sell a baseball team. There are not going to be any surprise Josh Hamilton announcements this offseason. Yet, maybe someday soon Yankee fans can wake up to the headline that they are free of the Hank, Hal, and Randy triumvirate.



52 Comments
Andrew Friedman December 10, 2012 00:22
You wish your GM was as good as me.
Breaking news December 10, 2012 11:31
The Yankees will likely re-sign Ichiro Suzuki, Ken Rosenthal of FOX Sports reported last night. The Yankees are showing strong interest in the free agent outfielder, Rosenthal writes. “They are all over him like an Asian guy on a bowl of rice,” one person told FOX Sports.
David Cone December 10, 2012 11:35
Like an Asian guy with a pair of chopsticks over a bowl of rice!
Racist Coney December 10, 2012 12:16
You are a Posteric. A Posteric is a dumb white person.
The Devil you don't know December 10, 2012 00:36
Wait till I buy the Yankees and sit on the money even more. The TV deal is set for decades so why add too much money to compete?
Kobe Bryant December 10, 2012 00:47
Lakers still suck worse.
Rey22 December 10, 2012 01:42
So when is the Nomaas slogan getting the update? Neither you nor the Yankees have $200 million burn anymore, and they will certainly lose plenty of games.
Well... December 10, 2012 09:14
They have WAY more than $200M to burn, especially with that $500M/yr extra from giving FOX a controlling ownership of the YES Network, but they are pocketing the money.
In English: The money is there, but Hank and Hal don’t give a shit about the Yankees or winning, so they are keeping the money, ’cause that’s what people who are already billionaires and have no personality do.
ESPN December 11, 2012 06:42
I think that was a one time 500 million. They bought the interest in yes, why pay yearly?
No December 12, 2012 00:47
The deal was several billion, to be paid over several seasons.
Tequila Sally December 10, 2012 01:51
Hamilton signs with,,,
Viktor Rostavili December 10, 2012 12:12
Jose Cuervo
Ki m Last December 12, 2012 09:51
Lumps
Kobe Bryant December 10, 2012 02:19
I met a Tequila Sally once. In a Colorado hotel actually.
Bud Selig December 10, 2012 03:05
It’s all coming together. Delicious.
Montgomery Burns (separated at birth from Bud) December 10, 2012 11:40
Excellent!
Pingback: The Yankees: Then & Now | NoMaas.org | Yankees News Source
Michale Corleone December 10, 2012 04:19
There are things being negotiated that are going to solve all your problems and answer all of your questions. That’s all I can say right now.
ESPN December 10, 2012 06:40
These JBs got it right! Forget murder suicide. Drunk driving with a bonus practice squad player dying? 30 for 30 gold bitches! Emmy time. Now please enjoy this commercial with a murderer talking to a young child.
Duh December 10, 2012 09:04
“Joel Sherman is still writing whole columns discussing the possibility of the Yankees signing Josh Hamilton!”
Joel Sherman is the same anti-Yankees asshole who tried to belittle Girardi in a post-game press conference, and picked a fight with him. He is a piece of shit who belongs in Beantown. As Rambo would say, “Fuck ‘em.”
Haha December 11, 2012 00:49
^^2 Red Sux fans.
LOL December 12, 2012 00:48
Make it three!
News Corp. December 10, 2012 09:10
We’ll buy the Yankees. Heck, we already own 80% of their TV network! And since we are FOX, Joe Buck can call the games. Imagine the YES channel, entirely geared towards shit-talking the Yankees; it would be a national sensation! Yankee fans may love the Yankees, but the rest of the sports fans hate them more than they love their own team! We could capitalize big time by making this network available nationwide.
*Evil laughs while folding hands *
Scott Boras December 10, 2012 10:09
Sigh… the good old days.
Bud Selig December 10, 2012 11:09
Good for you maybe. Good for the players. Good for the fans.
But for me and my wealthy cronies? Those were the Dark Ages.
Montgomery Burns (separated at birth from Bud) December 10, 2012 11:43
Excellent!
Excellent!
Smithers, ask Randy Levine to lube up.
Ned Colletti December 10, 2012 12:14
Sit on my lap Scotty. Tell me your worries.
Sam the butcher December 10, 2012 10:11
Be sure to fatten that calf before bringing it to slaughter.
Benny Blanco from Da Bronx December 10, 2012 11:24
This team will still win 90+ games!
Benny Blanco from Da Bronx December 10, 2012 11:25
And proibably make the post season.
Carlucci December 10, 2012 11:44
The Yankees will go the way I went on the subway train.
Pachanga December 10, 2012 12:15
You stupid bitch. I shouldn’t have listened to you. this team might crack 90 wins. Maybe.
Carlito December 10, 2012 11:45
Excuse me, I meant the way I went on the subway train.
Racist Coney December 10, 2012 12:16
Carlito ain’t no fucking TSJC. Look at the way he dances.
Mike Burke December 10, 2012 12:40
1966. It’s like deja vu all over my shirt.
Lefty from Mulberry St. December 10, 2012 12:50
My mother can hold her head high when she walks down the street, in all the 5 boroughs. I’m known all over the world. You ask anybody about Lefty from Mulberry St.
Justin Verlander, Clayton Kershaw, David Price, CC Sabathia, Felix Hernandez, Jered Weaver, Stephen Strasburg December 10, 2012 13:08
Wait, Zack Greinke is a top 5 pitcher? Huh?
Call me Crazy December 10, 2012 14:01
He was top-5 WAR in 2012, if you buy into hyper-composite stats.
Ahead of Sabathia and Weaver, tied with Price. (But 25th in 2011)
He would have been a Burnett-esque signing for the Yankees, but they have a point that in past years the Yankees would have been all over him.
Vizzini December 11, 2012 01:47
Yeah, fair point- top 5 may be a slight overreach. He is fifth in WAR among all pitchers over the last 5 seasons, so he’s not far off. But going forward, I’m largely with you. I’d take JV, Strasburg, Kershaw, Felix and Price ahead of Greinke. CC & Weaver are right there and Lee & Halladay certainly belong in the convo. Can we agree on top 10 and accept that the premise of the article still holds?
Call me Crazy December 10, 2012 13:52
Just wait until next year when Bud cock-block’s Mark Cuban’s bid for the Yankees, and they’re bought by a “group of investors” which is mostly News Corp. with Joe Torre as the baseball-insider as the face that gives the deal “legitimacy”. Hank and Hal go and retire, but they retain Levine because he’s the guy seen as having grown the business so big.
Wow December 10, 2012 14:42
As crazy as all of that is, it sounds perfectly possible– almost LIKELY. It makes sense and follows the trends we’ve been seeing. Interesting post.
Cervelli December 10, 2012 15:50
I can play backup catcher. hello? is this thing on?
Well SHIT... December 11, 2012 00:52
At this point, you would be the best choice the Yankees have in-house for a STARTING catcher. They keep swearing over and over again that they are not going to sign any catchers and that the position will be covered by minor-leaguers.
Josh Brent & Javon Belcher December 10, 2012 19:43
Pick your teammates wisely.
Rambo December 10, 2012 20:16
Fuck em.
Chau December 10, 2012 20:36
So why so extreme? It’s like only being gay or straight? Why Chau can’t play for both teams?
Long term contracts for past prime stars (gayboy Arod, Hamstring Tex) or overpays for league average talent (Burnett) are fucking stupid. 2009 is not a long term plan…with no juice guys in their mid 30s get old fast.
2012 has been a joke too. Greed is good bitches!
Given the age on the roster and the expiring contracts (boras has such an erection) CA$H should be all in this year in 2013 and then blow it up.. But the fans – and basement dweller bloggers – cry when they think of the decade and half run ending. Time to rebuild.
Suck it (stupid) gayboys.
Devil's Advocate December 10, 2012 21:43
Am I the only one considering they have a multi-year plan in place?
There hasn’t been a free agent class as strong as 2009 since.
This year’s class is especially weak.
Why shouldn’t their plan limit payroll until the time comes to massively expand during the best free agent class?
Wouldn’t this be the smartest way to build another dynasty?
Alpa Chino December 10, 2012 23:39
Have fun predicting which FA’s don’t get extensions, injured or get a case of the sucks down the road.
DormantUlcer December 12, 2012 09:50
Cain. Hamels. Should have been in this class.
Nick Swisher December 10, 2012 23:02
I have 1 million twitter followers but none of them are gm’s.
MIKE SILVA December 12, 2012 09:50
I WOULD LET YOU RAPE ME WITH A DILDO.
Matzo December 12, 2012 09:49
It would be nice if the beat writers asked why the need to go down to 189? To save a few million? At the expense of the brand, network ratings, empty ballpark?
Why isn’t Hamilton being wined and dined and asked what would it take? I guess we all forgot him killing us in the playoffs and the fact that he’d hit 50 homers in his sleep. But I guess Cashman and Hal didn’t see the feeble offense this year.